cicero jones
20 April 2007
  What can we do?
In response to the two previous entries (and ensuing comments) Anonymous said (bolding is mine):
Dearest Cicero,
While I completely agree with your point (and it is one that Rosie O’Donnell makes several times a week on The View), I have to present the other side as I see it. Yes, the media makes money with the art of distraction. However, Americans in general, have so many venues to choose from to receive their news: newspapers, magazines and tv programs that span the entire political spectrum, npr, endless websites, your blog. And while all of these are skewed, we have the basic option to choose what we want to read and when. And sometimes we just like to be distracted with Anna Nicole’s baby daddy because there is nothing we can do about the 4 year mess in Iraq. It’s not pleasant feeling so defeated all the time. I do admire your belief in achieving something better though, and if you have suggestions as to how the everyday citizen can help tackle mountains, please tell us.
J-lo responded:
I'd like to quickly comment on what anonymous had posted regarding the unpleasantness of feeling defeated. It is true that most of us may indeed feel defeated after the precarious situation our beloved president has entered us in, however, as Americans we can do something. There is a great quote by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr that states "The Greatest sin of our time is not the few who have destroyed, but the majority who have sat idly by." This is the case in point for most Americans who prefer to watch the next episode of twisted shows like 24 than take to the streets, join groups like MoveOn.org, send a heated letter to their representative, or simply vote. As Americans we've forgotten the power of voice and action. It's necessary that we demand action on the part of those politicians who claim they represent the public. Educate and speak your mind - teach your neighbor about the realities of Iraq and that 233 people dead in a single day is not a sign of success, but rather pandemonium - hell on Earth. Every little thing we do as activists, voters, citizens, does have an impact whether we believe it or not. We need to quit feeling defeated by a government that thrives on their ability to curb our civil liberties!
I understand where Anonymous is coming from. Sometimes it all becomes overwhelming. Many times, in fact, I can't even blog about things because I'm so frustrated and feel like I'm shouting into a black hole. But, as he or she mentions, there are plenty of media outlets for us to choose from - so how can it be a problem?

It is a problem because a singular media narrative seems to penetrate all of those different options. Take, for example, the lead up to the Iraq war. In the shadow of 9/11, the media just embraced Bush, his concept of an Axis of Evil, and the totally fabricated notion of Iraq posing some sort of imminent, Al Qaeda-linked threat to the United States. Over 80% of the American public bought this, because every single media outlet was selling it, and there was very little dissent. All of those scary graphics showing radical Islamist fighters running through obstacle courses and Saddam Hussein firing off a rifle made for good ratings, after all.

The point is then: what is variety when there is no diversity contained within it? This, in turn, brings me to J-lo's point, and his reference to MLK Jr. We cannot sit on our hands here and just say, "Oh well, it's the only thing on TV, so I'm gonna watch it." We have to be proactive. Action is as simple as speaking up, loudly and clearly, within your own group of friends. Action is going door to door as part of an organized voter education campaign (if you've never tried it, you'd be surprised at how easy and fun it is, and how many interesting people you'll meet along the way). Action is also being aware of the economics of media: don't be afraid to contact advertisers and let them know what you think about them associating themselves with certain networks or shows.

Above and beyond everything else, don't be afraid. Don't be afraid that you might step on someone's toes, or get yourself into a debate that might lead to some heated moments. It's your country too, and no matter the forum, you have a voice.

Labels:

 
Comments:
I find it ironic that you have the word ‘action’ in your label because your recommendation is basically ‘just talk more’. We all know the saying that actions speak louder than words. Hoping to inform and education other people is nice, but not always practical and in my opinion not really ACTION. To really get through to people, you have to repeat your message at least 7 times (this is proven in numerous marketing studies). So unless you plan on going door to door several times to the same customers, I’m sure those folks maybe thought about you for 5 minutes and then went back to their couch and flipped on “Deal or No Deal” (side note: this is THE dumbest show ever).
Sorry if I seem somewhat negative. But trust me, I’m not missing your point. I am that person that makes the phone call, writes the email, get my opinion out there. I believe in small steps creating a bigger movement. But let’s be practical. It’s not about our voice. We don’t have the actual power. Do you think multiconglomerate organizations even read my email? What would matter is rallying enough people to ACT in a way that financially impacts the people who have the power. Problem is, I’m not sure how to do that…
 
some great posts this week and some good responses. Your generation needs to get larger numbers engaged in the debate thru whatever means and media makes sense. My generation did that re Vietnam and racism, but many of us have now blended into safe lifestyles claiming to be too busy working/living to make a difference.But many of us have lived a good life and made some changes that are good and lasting.
You and your readers are grabbing the mantle . There is of course no signle way to do this, but rather it becomes all encompassing as you speak your mind to friends and families, campaign for those in whom you believe,vote with conviction and do so consistnet with real values. Make a difference every day and you will feel better, over time.
Do not feel despaired and do not give up. Your contributions help in samll ways, and perhaps in bigger ways none of you may ever know
it will take time, so enjoy the journey...speaking up with every step
 
Anonymous #1,

You state "unless you plan on going door to door several times to the same customers..."

Um, yeah, it's called organized canvassing. You hit people many times over the course of months, and rate them on their ability to empathize with your cause, and their level of commitment to it. It's a proven and very effective technique, used in democracies across the planet for many, many years.

And then, "It's not about our voice. We don't have the actual power." Are you kidding? What do you think political organizing is? We DO have power, precisely when WE are WE, and not a bunch of I's.

As far as action goes, building consensus within your own peer group, work group, whatever, is definitely action. How do you think change happens in a democracy? Precisely via individual leaders working to shape opinion within groups, and urging those groups to speak and vote in unison.

Regarding some things that we can do now in terms of economics, you can start by holding companies you do business with accountable for their actions. There used to be a website called buyblue.org, which listed progressive-friendly business, but that has unfortunately been shut down. However, check out http://www.bluefund.com/ - a mutual fund company that offers you the ability to invest in socially responsible companies. In fact, all public companies are taking greater strides than ever to meet the demands of their shareholders that they become more socially responsible and sustainable. Pick up a copy of the Wall Street Journal and I guarantee you'll see an article about some company giving into "green" pressure and doing the right thing.

I'm not sure where you live, but perhaps your local electric company has something like mine (Con Edison of NY) does, the ability to buy "green" power: http://www.poweryourway.com/pages/greenpower.html

Don't despair, and don't doubt the power of words to create consensus, and in turn actually create positive change.
 
Post a Comment

<< Home

now featuring regular commentary from J-lo
the wisdom lives
October 2004 / November 2004 / December 2004 / March 2005 / June 2005 / July 2005 / August 2005 / September 2005 / October 2005 / November 2005 / December 2005 / January 2006 / February 2006 / March 2006 / April 2006 / May 2006 / June 2006 / July 2006 / August 2006 / September 2006 / October 2006 / November 2006 / December 2006 / January 2007 / February 2007 / March 2007 / April 2007 / June 2007 / October 2007 /
word
  • the miseducation of kevo
  • faith and fear in flushing
  • the morning news
  • mcsweeney's
  • look
  • vuelta por el universo
  • useful
  • gothamist
  • brooklyn vegan
  • soccer on your television
  • metsblog
  • political wire
  • nyc weather
  • live national weather radar
  • DfA

    email me


    Powered by Blogger