cicero jones
21 June 2005
  Support for the war: enlisting?
I think about enlisting a lot. Both on a macro, society-wide level, and a personal one. I grew up assuming that, if my country ever needed me, I would enlist. I can't say I even questioned that belief too much -- both of my grandfathers were Marines (the older served in WWII in the Pacific and the younger in the Korean War) and it seemed natural. My father was never drafted during Vietnam; he was on the younger side of the draft pool, and probably would've not passed the physical anyway. There was a clear distinction in my mind there: my grandfathers went, because they had to, it was absolutely expected of men of their era; my dad wasn't needed and wasn't called.

So where are we now? Many left-wing bloggers are calling for Republicans to enlist, which, yes, makes sense. There are so many fucking chickenhawks out there, the delusional Believers who still think the war is going well, Bush is spreading freedom like it's cream cheese on a hot and crusty New York bagel. And, enlistment is plummeting. The Army needs people. They want the Army to be able to do its job. They should enlist. Bottom line.
But what about me? I didn't support the war. Certainly don't now. But as I see it, we created a massive nest/magnet for violent, radical Islamists in this country, destroyed any sense of security/stability there, and now have to effectively with that situation. Yes, I want our troops home, but seriously, how is that even possible right now? If we pull out there will be such a goddamn power vaccum, and the radicals will be able to expand the network of camps, training facilities, and ammunition dumps they already have there. That will certainly destabilize the region even more. So we need to stay, right? That's what they mean by quagmire, I suppose.
But, the most important point for me, I think, is that technically, yes, I think we need to keep troops there. The Army needs troops. Does the Army need me?

I'm calming myself in the way many in our not-in-my-backyard society do: I tell myself it's not a critical situation yet, and I never supported this war anyway. But, the way things are going, those arguments might not matter much longer.
 
Comments:
Enlist now?? Please don't. My son has been in the Air Force for 21 years - and was sent to Afghanistan at the beginning of the War and Iraq later! I agreed with searching for Osama Bin Laden - sh_t I would have done it myself if I could - I live in New York! I DID NOT AND DO NOT agree with the entire Iraq thing - always felt it was just to beef up Bush's image - he thought it would be a "quick win". I am not a Republican or Democrat but an Independent and have voted different ways in each election - but not for Bush! I happen to think that all of those who voted for the war in Iraq should have their own children join up - especially those with daughters!. My daughter was in the Air Force during Desert Storm! I believe that anyone who votes for a war should be willing to sacrifice their own lives or their children's lives in the decision- that is the true measure of support for "the right reason to go to war"!. I did it - why don't they! by the way - where is Osama Bin Laden - you never hear about him anymore- the Iraq war sure accomplished a lot didn't it!
 
I agree with you. I have been opposed to the war since Bush started fantasizing about it. I just don't see any easy way out, and I feel very uneasy about not serving when plenty of people my age are putting their lives on the line every day. Ideally, we will get out of there asap.
 
Post a Comment

<< Home

now featuring regular commentary from J-lo
the wisdom lives
October 2004 / November 2004 / December 2004 / March 2005 / June 2005 / July 2005 / August 2005 / September 2005 / October 2005 / November 2005 / December 2005 / January 2006 / February 2006 / March 2006 / April 2006 / May 2006 / June 2006 / July 2006 / August 2006 / September 2006 / October 2006 / November 2006 / December 2006 / January 2007 / February 2007 / March 2007 / April 2007 / June 2007 / October 2007 /
word
  • the miseducation of kevo
  • faith and fear in flushing
  • the morning news
  • mcsweeney's
  • look
  • vuelta por el universo
  • useful
  • gothamist
  • brooklyn vegan
  • soccer on your television
  • metsblog
  • political wire
  • nyc weather
  • live national weather radar
  • DfA

    email me


    Powered by Blogger